CMMC guide
Two Cyber False Claims Act Settlements, Same Weak Spot: SSP and POA&M
If you hold a defense contract, your security plan is now a legal document. Two cyber False Claims Act settlements this month both came back to the same two papers.
Capital Cyber Compliance, in Leesburg, Virginia, runs CMMC Level 2 gap assessments for small and mid-sized defense contractors.
What happened in those 10 days?
On November 3, 2026, DOJ announced that ILC Dover and ILC Astrospace agreed to pay $13 million. Their contracts were with the Army, the Missile Defense Agency and NASA.
On November 13, DOJ announced that Johnson Controls and two of its units agreed to pay $5 million. Their contracts were with NASA and the Departments of Defense, Energy and Justice.
Neither company admitted liability. DOJ says the claims are allegations only, with no finding of liability.
Why does DOJ care about cyber at all?
In 2021, DOJ launched its Civil Cyber-Fraud Initiative. It said it would use the False Claims Act against cyber fraud by contractors.
The idea is simple. If you tell the government you protect its data, that promise has to be true. These two cases show the initiative is still active.
What did both cyber False Claims Act cases have in common?
Both named the System Security Plan. Both named the Plan of Action and Milestones.
For ILC, DOJ alleged the security plans were not developed, documented or updated over time. It also alleged the POA&M was not developed or carried out.
For Johnson Controls, DOJ alleged the company did not keep an SSP that met its contract terms. It also alleged the POA&M was not documented, developed or carried out well enough.
That is the pattern. The plan was missing or out of date, and the work did not match.
What else went wrong at ILC?
DOJ alleged three more gaps.
- The cloud. A cloud provider storing CUI did not meet security equal to FedRAMP Moderate, from February 2023 to October 2024.
- The controls. NIST SP 800-171 and 800-53 controls were not fully in place.
- The score. ILC Astrospace never sent DoD a current NIST SP 800-171 assessment. ILC Dover sent one that was not current.
That last point is the self-assessment score DoD contractors post in SPRS. DOJ did not use the word SPRS, but that is where the score lives.
What else went wrong at Johnson Controls?
DOJ alleged the company did not control access to protected data. The reason given: it lacked enough knowledge of, and control over, its own systems.
Put plainly, you cannot protect what you cannot see. An asset list and a clear boundary come before every other control.
Who brought these cases?
Insiders did. The ILC case was filed by its former Director of Cybersecurity. One of the Johnson Controls cases was filed by a former employee.
The False Claims Act lets private people report fraud. They can share in what the government recovers. So the people who know your gaps best are your own staff.
Does this mean my shop is next?
Not by itself. But both cases turned on paperwork any small supplier also has.
Is your SSP stale? Does your POA&M list items nobody is working? Then you carry the same kind of risk.
The good news is that every gap DOJ named can be checked in a week.
What should I check this week?
- Read your SSP against reality. Walk the shop. Does the plan match every system, user and data flow you see?
- Make your POA&M real. Each open item needs an owner, a date and proof of progress. Close or update anything stale.
- Confirm your assessment score is current. Check the date of the NIST SP 800-171 self-assessment you posted. Redo it if your systems changed.
- Get proof from your cloud provider. If a cloud service stores your CUI, get written proof it meets FedRAMP Moderate or its equal.
- Give staff a way to speak up inside. Set a simple channel for security concerns, and act on what comes in.
None of this needs new tools. It needs an honest look and a dated record.
Next step: if you want a second set of eyes on your SSP and POA&M, book a gap assessment.
Sources
Questions contractors ask
FAQWhat is a cyber False Claims Act case?
It is a case where the government says a contractor claimed to meet cyber rules it did not meet. DOJ uses the False Claims Act to pursue these cases. Its Civil Cyber-Fraud Initiative began in 2021 for exactly this purpose.
How much did ILC Dover and Johnson Controls pay?
ILC Dover and ILC Astrospace agreed to pay $13 million. Johnson Controls and two of its units agreed to pay $5 million. Neither company admitted liability. DOJ says the claims are allegations only.
What does this mean for my business?
It means your SSP and POA&M must match how your systems really work. Both settlements named those two documents. Check your plan against your shop, date every open item, and confirm your assessment score is current.
Can an employee bring a False Claims Act case?
Yes. The law lets private people report fraud and share in any recovery. Both of these cases were brought by insiders, including ILC's former Director of Cybersecurity.
Already know you want to talk?
BOOK A CALLSkip the form. Pick a time and talk to us directly.
What happens in 30 minutes
- We learn about your business and the defense contracts you hold or are bidding on.
- We walk you through a gap assessment, the first step toward CMMC, and what it covers.
- If you qualify, we help you apply to Cyber Grants Alliance for an in-kind grant, which provides the gap assessment itself. No slides.
Defense supplier under 75 people? Start with the grant.
Cyber Grants Alliance, a nonprofit, awards in-kind cybersecurity grants. It provides the work itself, including CMMC Level 1 and Level 2 gap assessments. There is no cost to you, and you are under no obligation to buy anything afterward, from us or from anyone.

