CMMC guide
What a C3PAO Assessment Looks Like, Day by Day
A C3PAO assessment is decided by the work you do before the assessor arrives. Here is what happens before, during and after.
Capital Cyber Compliance, in Leesburg, Virginia, runs CMMC Level 2 gap assessments for small and mid-sized defense contractors.
What is a Level 2 C3PAO assessment?
An assessor works through all 110 NIST SP 800-171 requirements with three methods.
They examine the documents and settings. They interview the people who run them. They test that each control does what the System Security Plan says.
It takes a few days on site or on screen, after weeks of preparation. A set window follows to close anything left open.
The Department of War has suspended the third party assessor rule before award, pending a review. The method below is also how a government led assessment runs, and it is what the review may bring back.
What has to exist before the assessor arrives?
The six weeks before decide the result.
- The scope, on paper. Every asset is sorted into one of five categories. The assessor asks first for four artifacts: the CUI flow diagram, the network boundary diagram, the physical site diagram, and the authorized user list. Missing any of them is the most common day one finding.
- A current System Security Plan. One document describes the boundary and how each of the 110 requirements is met, naming the people and systems. It is read first, and every later question refers back to it.
- The evidence index. For each requirement, where the proof lives: the settings export, the dated screenshot, the log extract, the training record, the ticket. Assessors work from 320 assessment objectives under the 110 requirements. Each objective needs its own proof, not a shared paragraph.
- The people, named. That means the executive who signs the affirmation, the day to day program owner, and whoever does the technical work, often the IT provider. Add department leads: HR for screening and departures, operations for physical access and visitors. Each is interviewed on their own part.
Should we do a readiness review?
Yes, a few weeks before. Have someone other than the people who built the controls run it, while there is still time to close gaps.
What happens on day one?
Day one is orientation and scope. The assessor checks the boundary against the diagrams and the asset list, and walks the site or its virtual version.
They check that what is in scope on paper matches the network. If the boundary does not hold, the assessment stops here.
How does the assessor check each requirement?
Family by family, with three methods.
Examine. The assessor reads the policy, the procedure and the settings. Not a summary: the real conditional access rules, firewall rules and backup history.
Interview. The person in charge explains how it works in practice, in their own words. The point is consistency.
If the procedure says the office manager removes accounts within one day, and the office manager says IT does it eventually, the control is not met.
Test. Where a control can be exercised, the assessor does it.
Log in without the second factor and watch it fail. Plug in a USB drive and watch the block. Pull the log for a named action and see the user, the time and the system.
Evidence sets the pace: a shop with an evidence index covers twenty requirements in a morning. A shop hunting for screenshots covers five.
What happens after the C3PAO assessment?
The assessor reports each requirement as met or not met, with the objective that failed. If every requirement is met, the result is final.
If a limited set of items is open, the assessment can end with them on a plan of action. They must close within 180 days or the result lapses.
Some requirements must be in place for the assessment to end at all. The plan is for finishing a nearly complete program, not starting one.
A final Level 2 result is valid for three years, with a yearly affirmation by a senior official. The affirmation outlives the assessor: a named officer signs that the controls still work.
What five things end an assessment early?
- No System Security Plan, or one that describes a different company. The SSP is a requirement in its own right (CA.L2-3.12.4).
- A boundary that does not hold. CUI turns up on a laptop, personal phone or file share the diagrams call out of scope.
- No multifactor authentication, or MFA on admins only with everyone else on passwords.
- An IT provider or cloud service that handles CUI with no written split of duties. The assessor expects a responsibility matrix for every outside provider in scope.
- Policies written for the assessment. Think documents dated last month, training all done the same afternoon, or log retention changed the week before. Assessors read timestamps.
How long does it take, and what does it cost?
Lead times and fees change. When this guide was written, assessor availability ran months out. The fee for a small company sat in the tens of thousands, which is why readiness work is where money is best spent.
Next step: our program leadership service runs the preparation from the first gap assessment through the assessment itself.
Questions contractors ask
FAQWhat does the suspended C3PAO requirement mean for my business?
You still need to prepare. The self assessment, the SPRS score and the affirmation are still required, government led assessments continue, and the review may restore the requirement. Preparation is the same work either way.
Can my IT provider sit in the assessment?
Yes, and they should, for the requirements they operate. The assessor will interview them about their part and will ask for the written split of responsibilities.
What if we fail one requirement?
A limited set of open items can go on a plan of action with a 180 day window. Some requirements cannot be left open. The assessor tells you which during the assessment.
How long is the result good for?
Three years, with an annual affirmation in between.
Is an assessment the same as an audit?
Close. An audit checks a sample. A CMMC assessment covers all 110 requirements and all of their objectives, every time.
Already know you want to talk?
BOOK A CALLSkip the form. Pick a time and talk to us directly.
What happens in 30 minutes
- We learn about your business and the defense contracts you hold or are bidding on.
- We walk you through a gap assessment, the first step toward CMMC, and what it covers.
- If you qualify, we help you apply to Cyber Grants Alliance for an in-kind grant, which provides the gap assessment itself. No slides.
Defense supplier under 75 people? Start with the grant.
Cyber Grants Alliance, a nonprofit, awards in-kind cybersecurity grants. It provides the work itself, including CMMC Level 1 and Level 2 gap assessments. There is no cost to you, and you are under no obligation to buy anything afterward, from us or from anyone.

